Depop vs. Poshmark for sellers: 2025 guide

Depop vs. Poshmark isn’t some “pick your football team” situation. Choose wrong, and you’re buried in fees, late shipments, or ghost-town listings. Depop brings the aesthetic, low fees, and Gen Z energy. Poshmark gives you a massive U.S. audience and shipping that doesn’t make you cry.

But real resellers don’t pick sides: They list on both, and let Nifty handle the data entry and analytics while they chase actual profit.

Depop vs. Poshmark: The quick look

• Depop is best for sellers with trendy, aesthetic pieces like Y2K, streetwear, or vintage. The crowd’s younger, the vibe’s global, and the fees are lower.
  ‍
  
• Poshmark is best for sellers who want structure, easy U.S. shipping, and buyers who love brands. It’s streamlined, reliable, and made to move inventory fast.

What real sellers say about Nifty

Still debating whether it's worth it to sell on Poshmark and Depop at the same time? Sellers using Nifty are scaling and leaving the guessing to others. And the results speak for themselves.

Take Wayne, or KayWayShop, a full-time seller who uses Nifty to manage listings across eBay, Poshmark, and Depop. (You should definitely check out those videos!)

In one day, he cleared 17 total sales: 8 from eBay, 6 from Poshmark, and 3 from Depop. If he had stuck to just one platform, most of those would’ve never happened.

“Crosslisting manually isn’t realistic. I would’ve had eight orders max. Nifty gave me 17.”

That’s the power of removing manual steps. Nifty goes way beyond blind listing; it’s about the fine-grained, gritty work behind the scenes that other tools leave to you.

What do sellers say makes Nifty different?

• Smart inventory management: When an item sells on Poshmark, Nifty updates quantity or removes it from Depop and eBay instantly. The double-selling panic is gone, gone, gone.
  
  
• Offer automation that actually works: With timed discounts and optional personal messages, sellers close more deals without having to look at their inbox every 2 seconds.
  
  
• Bulk relisting and quantity tools: Nifty recognizes when your eBay listing is about to expire, ends it early, and creates a new one to refresh its spot in search. That means more exposure without extra fees.
  
  
• Sales analytics that show you profit, not just numbers: The platform pulls in your cost of goods, shipping, fees, and even top brands, giving you real answers on what’s worth keeping and what to stop listing.

“I used to track everything in spreadsheets. Now I just log in and all my profit and loss data is ready. I don’t touch Excel anymore.”

The same seller also noted that he stuck with Nifty through the rebrand from Auto Posher because the platform kept getting better. He’s tried other crosslisting platforms, and even got paid to promote them, but kept coming back to Nifty because the setup, inventory management, and reporting were cleaner and faster.

Whether you're already juggling both platforms or wondering if it’s worth selling on Poshmark and Depop at once, Nifty makes the answer a lot easier to say yes to.

“If I had to go back to doing this manually, I wouldn’t. Not even for a week.”

Basically, it’s a no-brainer at this point. And if you’re looking for another in-depth review, you can’t go wrong with this one by “Don’t B Trippin’, It’s Just Flippin’.” (We love the name!)

Depop vs. Poshmark: Feature-by-feature comparison

Knowing the difference between Depop and Poshmark is not a matter of style, it’s about fees, shipping, buyer behavior, and how much time you’ll waste trying to fix things that should have worked.

Some differences are obvious. Others hit you after your first canceled order or lowball offer. This section breaks it all down with real numbers, seller experience, and a verdict for each feature.

Core audience

Depop works a younger, international crowd: The platform is stacked with Gen Z buyers and sellers who care about aesthetics, trend cycles, and individuality. It’s popular for Y2K, vintage, handmade, and streetwear fashion. If your pieces feel TikTok-core or thrifted-with-intent, you’ll feel at home here.

Poshmark is for an older, mostly U.S.-based audience. Shoppers are often looking for popular brands at a discount. The platform is ideal for flipping mall-label clothes, athletic wear, and designer items, especially when they come bundled.

Winner: Depop takes the win for its unique, trend-forward sellers. Poshmark wins for brand-aware U.S. shoppers looking for easy deals.

Platform aesthetic

Depop feels like a style blog in motion. Profiles look like social pages, and listing photos are the star of the show. (And don’t miss out on the Depop scrunch!) You sell a jacket and a vibe; aesthetic matters, and buyers expect creativity.

Poshmark is the digital version of a clean, no-nonsense closet. Listings are structured, filtering is practical, and there’s less pressure to perform. You’re selling clothes, not curating an identity. (If you’re a Virgo, you’ve already planted your flag here.)

Winner: Depop, if you want your brand to look cool while making money. Poshmark, if you want to skip the fluff and get paid.

Fees

Since mid-2024, Depop sellers no longer pay a cut to the platform. Instead, there’s a 3.3% plus 45-cent payment processing fee in the U.S. This setup makes higher-value sales a lot more profitable. 

Poshmark charges 20% on everything over $15, and a flat $2.95 on anything under. Great if you’re selling a $10 tank. Brutal if you just sold a hundred-dollar jacket. (Check out the Poshmark blog on this.) 

Winner: Depop, simply because you’ll get higher margins. 

Shipping

Depop gives you options. You can set your own rates, ship internationally, or use their labels. That flexibility is a lifesaver if you’re selling lightweight pieces or want to keep global buyers in the mix. The normal range is from $4.49 to $13 and change. 

Poshmark is more “one and done.” You get a prepaid USPS label. It’s fast and simple, but at a flat $8.27 for (only!) 5 lb or less, it’s also a bit much for small stuff. And international buyers? Not happening.

Winner: Depop, if you want more control and choice. Poshmark, if you want to quickly slap on a label and move on to your next sale.

Social features

Depop wants you to build a brand. Followers, likes, messages, comment threads, it’s resale with a personality. For creators with a bit of flair, that’s gold.

Poshmark wants you to share listings. Over and over. There’s no direct messaging. You can comment on listings and send DMs via bundles in the private comments areas. However, true visibility depends on how often you play the share game. It works, but it’s work.

Winner: Depop, if you want real engagement. Poshmark, if you've got time to click and click and click again.

Returns

Depop lets sellers decide how to handle returns. That means more freedom, but also more risk. Support can be slow, and you're stuck dealing with unhappy buyers directly.

Poshmark handles those disputes for you. If a buyer claims an issue, the platform steps in (yeah, they’re cool like that). It’s more structured, but you might lose control of the outcome. 

Winner: Depop, if you like running your shop your way. Poshmark, if you prefer rules and useful backup.

Best for

Depop is great for sellers with aesthetic-driven inventory, one-of-a-kind pieces, or anything that looks like it belongs in a thrifted TikTok haul. If you like control, international reach, and buyers who care more about style than labels, this is your playground.

Poshmark is a match made in heaven for sellers who want structure, branded fashion, and a big U.S. audience that knows how to check out. It’s perfect for flipping mall brands, shipping with zero guesswork, and scaling fast, if you don’t mind the fees. 

Winner: Depop, if your inventory is niche and styled. Poshmark, if you want structure and fast-moving branded pieces.

User reviews

Forget glossy platform claims. Here’s what real sellers are saying about selling on Depop vs. Poshmark, pulled straight from Reddit and Trustpilot, two of the most merciless spots on the internet. 

Depop: What users think

Depop gets love for creative freedom, low fees, and its boutique-style experience. But sellers are quick to warn about scams, weak support, and PayPal problems.

I prefer selling on Depop. UI’s much cleaner. Has more of a boutique vibe if you work on your shop … shipping is flexible, and you can use Depop shipping labels, but requires you to figure out if your package is small, medium, large, or XL.
— u/PuffinTheMuffin, Reddit

I ditched Depop because I couldn’t stand working with PayPal. I lost money and items in two scams, and Depop did very little to help, so I had to fight through PayPal.
— u/aygswa, Same thread

Pros

• No selling fee
  
• Clean interface, great for vintage or boutique branding
  
• International shipping options

Cons:

• Poor scam handling, weak support
• Must handle disputes through PayPal
  
• Offers not binding, lots of flaking
  
• Slower payouts (2+ days after delivery)

*Cons taken from the 1.3-star average on Trustpilot

Poshmark: What users think

Poshmark gets lots of love for its structure and shipping flow, but fees and buyer behavior get called out. Most sellers agree that visibility takes a lot of effort. 

I don’t want to deal with hagglers, which Poshmark promotes. They also push automatic free returns. It encourages scams.
— u/PuffinTheMuffin

Poshmark was a huge [challenge] to get used to, but I love it now. You just have to deal with lowball offers and slow payouts if buyers don’t approve.
— u/thriftkat

Pros

• Prepaid shipping
  
• Strong buyer protection
  
• Larger audience, especially in the U.S.
  
• Payouts you can trust (after buyer confirmation)

Cons

• 20% fee hurts on big-ticket items
  
• Constant closet sharing is necessary for visibility
  
• Returns are handled by the platform, not you
  
• Not really “global” per se

There isn’t a huge difference in Trustpilot reviews between Poshmark Canada (1.8) and Poshmark U.S. (1.2). Poshmark Canada is also rated 1.7 on PissedConsumer. Mostly, the bad reviews come from people who’ve received poor seller support, and who’ve been the victims of scams – we’ve got a guide to help you out there.

Fees & profit margins: Let’s do the math

You can’t pick a resale platform without asking the one question that actually matters: How much do I keep? Below are real, side-by-side examples comparing Depop vs. Poshmark across three price points.

All calculations use 2025 fee policies.

• Depop: No platform fee, just 3.3% + $0.45 payment processing (U.S.)
  
• Poshmark: Flat $2.95 fee under $15, 20% commission on anything over

Here’s how it shakes out:

What does this actually mean?

• On a $75 jacket, you make $12.08 more on Depop
  
• On a $120 bag, you keep nearly $20 more
  
• On a basic $20 tee, the gap is just over $2.80, but enough to matter at scale

Unlike Poshmark, where payouts hinge on the buyer saying “Yes,” Depop just sends your money 2 days after confirmed delivery. No waiting for someone to tap “Accept.”

Why do many sellers use both anyway?

If you’re deep into selling on Depop vs. Poshmark, here’s the catch: They each rule in different ways. Depop gives you global reach and lower fees. Poshmark makes shipping simple and offers stronger buyer protection. 

However, for a lot of sellers, picking just one means leaving easy money on the table.

What makes crosslisting across platforms a huge pain?

• Twice the listings, none of the automation: You have to write, upload, and tweak everything by hand. One typo? That alone will cost you 10 minutes.
  
  
• Inventory management turns into Excel hell: Sell an item on Depop and forget to remove it from Poshmark? Congrats, you’re now apologizing with an “oops, already sold” moment. We know no one likes those, on either side.
  
  
• Pricing updates become a guessing game: Want to run a sale or update costs on 30 items? Better clear your afternoon.
  
  
• No shared analytics, no way to compare performance: One platform might be beating the other, but you’ll never know without manual math.

Why do sellers double-list, even with the extra work?

• Depop grabs Gen Z buyers you’d never reach on Poshmark
  
• Poshmark sells more mid-range and designer fashion at higher volumes
  
• One item might flop on one platform but sell instantly on the other
  
• Combining both means fewer slow days and more consistent sales

Where Nifty steps in to save the day

Crosslisting across resale sites like Poshmark and Depop sounds like a power move, until you’re four hours deep into duplicating listings, updating descriptions, and tracking profits in four different tabs. Most sellers either burn out or give up before they scale.

That’s exactly where Nifty is a lifesaver. It connects Poshmark, Depop, eBay, Mercari, and Etsy in one interface and takes all the guesswork out of multi-platform selling. 

What Nifty handles so you don’t lose sales (or your mind)

• Create one listing, launch it everywhere: Nifty builds and lists across supported platforms super quick. That means photos, pricing, item condition, hashtags, and all those dropdowns don’t have to be redone five times.
  
  
• Auto-delist sold items instantly: Nifty automatically detects and auto-delists sales, and it’s all on the cloud, so it’s hands-free. When something sells on Poshmark, Nifty removes it from Depop, Mercari, and everywhere else it's listed. Your stock is kept consistent across marketplaces, which saves you from those awkward refund messages because you forgot to update your inventory.
  
  
• Keep pricing consistent across platforms: Want to raise prices for international buyers or run a limited sale? Nifty lets you bulk edit prices across all platforms without logging in and out of each one.
  
  
• Track real profits, not just sales numbers: Nifty breaks down profit by item, category, and platform. It parses fees automatically and even includes the cost of goods, so you know exactly what’s making you money.
  
  
• Automate the work Posh Sidekick can’t touch: Posh Sidekick (aka Sidekick Tools) focuses on Poshmark automation (shares, follows, parties) and doesn’t help you manage Depop or scale on any other resale site. Nifty covers them all and goes even further with listing creation, crossposting, delisting, bulk tools, and deeper analytics.
  
  
• Nifty’s bulk tools help you scale without a hiring spree: Update descriptions, tags, and prices in batches. Schedule sharing and relists. Reactivate stale listings in one click. Nifty keeps your store fresh while you focus on sourcing and hopefully enjoying some free time. 

Depop vs. Poshmark: Should you choose at all? 

Still stuck between selling on Depop vs. Poshmark? We definitely feel you. Both platforms have a lot to offer, and knowing which one fits your style (and sanity level) can save you hours and keep more money in your pocket.

Here’s the no-fluff lowdown:

Yes, just sell on both platforms with Nifty

Comparing Depop vs. Poshmark is the first step. If you're selling on both, the real challenge is managing listings, shipping, and profits without spending your weekend staring at your laptop.

That’s where Nifty comes in: It’s the best AI command hub for crosslisting, automation, and analytics.

• AI listing moves: Snap a pic and let Nifty’s AI build a boss-level listing, with SEO-optimized titles and descriptions, trending hashtags, and every dropdown already filled out for you.
  
  
• Crosslist now: With a couple of clicks, post your items across Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, Depop, Etsy, and more. No copy-paste, no multi-tab hell.
  
  
• Automatic delisting? Handled: When you make a sale, Nifty pulls that item from every marketplace, so say goodbye to double-selling disasters and “sorry, it’s already gone” apology messages.
  
  
• Bulk tools = no busywork: Relist, update, or discount dozens of items at once. Schedule everything and keep your store looking fresh as we run your updates in the background.
  
  
• Analytics and profits are real: Track sales, fees, top performers, and slow movers in one clean interface, so you can actually see what’s working and what’s just dead space.

Start your 7-day free trial today, and see how Nifty can make your reselling experience so much easier.

FAQs

1. What’s the best resale platform for sellers in 2025?

It depends on what you’re selling. Poshmark wins for brand-name volume. Depop wins for style and global reach. Most resellers use both, they just don’t do it manually, they use Nifty.

2. How long does it take to get paid on Depop vs. Poshmark?

Depop pays two days after delivery confirmation. Poshmark can take up to three days unless the buyer approves it faster. Your payout speed depends on how polite your customer is.

3. Can I sell new items on Poshmark?

Yep, just tag them NWT and make sure they look and are brand-new. But expect more questions and more picky buyers if you price like a store.

4. Is Depop worth it if you only sell locally?

Only if your stuff sells itself on looks. Without shipping reach or visual appeal, you’re better off on eBay or Facebook Marketplace with porch pickups and ghosted messages.

5. Can I track trends across both platforms?

Nifty pulls analytics from Poshmark, Depop, and more. You’ll see what sells fastest, what makes the most profit, and what needs to get dropped from your store lineup.

6. What happens if I forget to delist an item after it sells?

You’ll have to cancel the sale and refund a pissed-off buyer. Most sellers either build a checklist or just use Nifty to handle auto-delist before it turns into a support nightmare.

7. What kind of buyer is on Depop compared to Poshmark?

Depop buyers care about aesthetics, uniqueness, and cool photos. Poshmark buyers often want a discount on that top they saw in a department store last month.

8. Can I crosslist on mobile?

If you're doing it manually, sure, but get ready to open five apps and paste your heart out. With a tool like Nifty, it's way faster and less painful.

9. Does Depop offer seller protection?

Not really. You’re expected to resolve disputes on your own, usually through PayPal. Sellers typically say support is hit or miss, especially on fraud cases.

10. What’s the biggest difference between Depop and Poshmark?

Control. Depop lets you customize shipping, returns, pricing, everything. Poshmark does it all for you, but you pay in fees and flexibility.