Vinted vs. Poshmark: Pros, cons, and the best marketplace for you | 2025

Vinted offers zero seller fees but limited social features, while Poshmark charges 20% commission but provides powerful community-driven discovery tools. 

Vinted vs. Poshmark depends on your selling priorities. Sellers on both platforms must use different reselling strategies. 

In this article, we’ll break down Vinted vs. Poshmark in detail, from fees and discovery to shipping and tools. We’ll also show you how tools like Nifty can help sellers scale smarter on specific platforms and manage their inventory in one place.

Vinted vs. Poshmark: At a glance

Meet Vinted: No-fee fashion marketplace

Founded in Lithuania in 2008, Vinted operates as a no-fee fashion marketplace that hosts over 100 million users across Europe and North America. Sellers list secondhand clothing, shoes, and accessories without paying commission fees, unlike other sites that often charge 10–20% per sale. 

Meet Poshmark: Social selling for fashion-focused resellers

Poshmark caters to fashion-focused resellers through its community-driven marketplace, serving over 130 million users across North America. Sellers share listings every day and regularly participate in Posh Parties, themed events where users share listings to boost visibility and connect with targeted buyers. 

Poshmark charges a 20% commission, making it one of the more expensive Vinted alternatives. 

Have more questions about Poshmark? Read our article.

Vinted vs. Poshmark: Feature breakdown

Vinted and Poshmark differ in their approach to seller fees, item discovery, listing processes, and seller tools. Vinted eliminates seller commissions but charges buyers service fees, whereas Poshmark charges sellers 20% but provides social discovery features. 

Both platforms offer mobile-friendly listing tools, but Poshmark adds community features like sharing and parties, which Vinted lacks.

Vinted seller fees

Vinted is a Poshmark alternative that eliminates seller fees entirely, so sellers keep the full listing price without commissions. Buyers cover all transaction costs through service fees of 3–8% plus fixed amounts, depending on purchase value and location.

The platform generates revenue exclusively from buyer-side charges, creating a seller-friendly structure that appeals to profit-focused resellers. Sellers can maximize profit margins on every Vinted sale.

Vinted’s downside is that buyer-paid fees increase total purchase costs. Some buyers think these fees are too high, which pushes them to shop for the same products on other platforms. Yet, Vinted still has a user base of over 100 million, larger than many other reselling websites. 

Poshmark seller fees

Poshmark charges sellers 20% commission on sales over $15 and a flat $2.95 fee on sales under $15. The platform justifies these costs with seller services like prepaid shipping labels, buyer protection, and social tools that boost visibility.

High commission fees significantly reduce profit margins compared to zero-fee competitors, and mandatory sharing creates time-consuming obligations that burden casual sellers.

The verdict

Vinted wins on seller fees with its zero-commission structure. Poshmark’s 20% fees are high, so sellers must price items carefully to profit. However, sellers prioritizing sales volume and those selling authenticated products will benefit from selling on Poshmark despite higher costs.

Vinted: Discovery and buyer reach

Vinted relies primarily on search algorithms and category browsing to connect buyers with sellers’ listings. The platform uses keyword matching, size filters, brand searches, and location-based discovery to surface relevant items.

The clean search interface helps buyers discover products through browsing rather than social features. However, Vinted’s limited promotional tools and social features limit sellers' ability to boost visibility beyond organic search.

Poshmark: Discovery and buyer reach

Poshmark combines traditional search with social discovery through sharing, following, and community-building Posh Parties and Posh Shows. These are seller-hosted livestreams where products reach targeted buyers.

Sellers must actively share listings to maintain visibility, as the platform prioritizes recently shared items in search results. Community events and social features create multiple discovery pathways beyond basic search functions. 

These social features help sellers amplify their product visibility, providing targeted exposure to buyers interested in specific brands, styles, or categories. Yet, this dependence on social activity disadvantages sellers who prefer passive listing strategies without community participation.

The verdict

Poshmark wins discovery and buyer reach through its social features and active community engagement tools. Vinted offers straightforward search-based discovery, but Poshmark's sharing system, Posh Parties, Posh Shows, and social features create multiple pathways for buyers to find seller listings. 

Vinted listing

Vinted’s listing tools are built for simplicity and speed. Sellers can quickly upload photos, write descriptions, choose categories, and set prices through a clean interface. 

Its mobile-configured interface makes Vinted convenient for listing items on the go with a smartphone. You can also create item bundles of up to 5 pieces in a single listing, which helps move more items at once. But Vinted lacks bulk features like CSV uploads or mass imports.

Poshmark listing

Poshmark offers several listing features that help sellers build engaging product pages. The platform includes cover photo selection, detailed descriptions, size selection fields, and brand categorization.

The platform supports bulk actions like bulk listing (Ambassador-exclusive), sharing, sending offers, and editing prices across multiple listings, though each item still needs to be manually selected. For faster scaling, Poshmark Ambassadors can use the bulk upload tool to create several listings at once with a spreadsheet template.

The verdict

Poshmark leads in listing capabilities with bulk actions and tools that support scaling sellers. Vinted focuses on simple, mobile-friendly uploads, but Poshmark's bulk listing features, spreadsheet templates for Ambassadors, and mass editing capabilities serve volume sellers better.

Vinted: Tools and inventory management

Vinted provides basic inventory management through its simple seller dashboard that displays active listings, sold items, and earnings summaries. It focuses on essential tools without advanced analytics or automation features, appealing to sellers who prefer straightforward inventory tracking.

Although it features simple, low-learning-curve tools, Vinted’s limited analytics limit sellers from spotting top items or optimization opportunities.

Poshmark: Tools and inventory management

Poshmark’s seller tools include detailed analytics dashboards, product performance tracking, and a listing tool. The platform’s analytics tool, My Closet Insights, helps sellers track sales, inventory, and order metrics. It provides detailed insights by brand, category, and time period, accessible through the app or web dashboard.

The platform’s listing tool, Smart List AI, auto-generates listing titles, descriptions, and details from photos. It works on iOS and Android mobile devices, helping sellers save time by generating search-friendly content in a snap.

The verdict

Poshmark takes the tools and inventory management cake through its proprietary analytics and AI generation capabilities. Although Vinted offers simple tools suited for casual sellers, Poshmark's tools serve growing businesses better. Professional resellers benefit from Poshmark's data-driven insights that optimize performance and scale operations.

Vinted: Shipping and returns

Vinted lets buyers pay shipping, and the platform adds it to the order total at checkout. The marketplace uses USPS and provides sellers with a printout when the buyer makes the purchase.

Shipping rates depend on the parcel size and the locations of both the buyer and the seller. When an item sells, Vinted sends a prepaid shipping label to the seller’s email and inbox. 

Sellers can also provide custom shipping through a carrier of their choice and add the shipping cost to their item pricing. 

Poshmark: Shipping and returns

Like Vinted, Poshmark charges buyers for shipping at the time of purchase, providing sellers with a prepaid USPS Priority Mail label for packages weighing up to 5 lbs. As of September 12th, 2025, shipping is a flat $6.49 paid by the buyer if the package weighs 5 lbs or less. Sellers must pay extra if the item is over 5 lbs.

Sellers also get access to free USPS boxes. Packages can be dropped off at a USPS or Canada Post location, scheduled for pickup, or mailed from home. Poshmark only supports shipping in North America. Poshmark also notes that orders will ship via USPS Ground Advantage, and delivery will take 2 to 5 business days. Sellers can also pay extra for Priority Mail. 

The verdict

Both platforms offer simple shipping for light packages. If Poshmark sellers ship packages over 5 lbs, they must pay the extra cost. Vinted offers international shipping, which Poshmark does not. Poshmark is ideal for North American sellers reaching North American buyers. Yet, sellers outside of North America may find Vinted more attractive. 

What real users say

We looked through and analyzed user reviews on Reddit, Trustpilot, and Reviews.io to provide some actual feedback about Vinted and Poshmark. 

Vinted pros

• Positive despite a few hiccups: A user praised Vinted for affordability and variety, sharing examples of scoring costumes and dresses at bargain prices. They liked haggling, real product photos, and seller communication. (August 2nd, 2025)

• Reliable app for buying and selling: A user shared satisfaction with Vinted, praising it as a useful and honest app for both buying and selling. They highlighted that Vinted provides payment even when shipments are delayed or lost. (April 26th, 2025)

• Smooth selling experience: One reviewer praised Vinted’s intuitive app, noting it takes just minutes to list items and charges no seller fees. Since starting in August 2024, they’ve sold over 80 items without issues. (December 19th, 2024)

Vinted cons

• Smaller US audience, and possibility of scams: One reviewer advised using caution on Vinted, noting its smaller U.S. user base compared to Poshmark. They recommended buying only from sellers with multiple reviews and being wary of deals that seem too good to be true. (May 29th, 2025)

• Slow sales: A user shared frustration with Vinted, saying they only made $7 from two sales in three months, making the platform feel slow and stagnant. (March 11th, 2025)

• Poor customer service and seller support: One user expressed deep frustration with Vinted, citing no accessible customer service, unanswered emails, and concerns about scams and tax compliance. (August 13th, 2025)

Poshmark pros

• Positive Poshmark experience with strong support: A user shared that they enjoyed both buying and selling on Poshmark, with minor issues resolved quickly and fairly. They highlighted making around $20,000 in a year from selling, praising the platform’s reliability and helpful customer support. (July 18th, 2025)

• Longtime Poshmark user praises positive experience: One user expressed surprise at negative reviews, saying they’ve bought and sold on Poshmark since 2019. They credited mature sellers and careful review-checking for smooth transactions. (May 8th, 2025)

• Pleasant first experience buying on Poshmark: A user described their first Poshmark purchase as enjoyable, with items arriving quickly and in excellent condition. They appreciated the friendly sellers and lively live sales. (January 2025) 

Poshmark cons

• Growing frustrations with Poshmark as a buyer and seller: One user shared that after years of buying and selling on Poshmark, the platform now feels more frustrating than rewarding. They’re tired of constant lowball offers and receiving clothing with foul odors, even when listed as new. (November 14th, 2024)

• Frustration with Poshmark’s handling of returns: A user strongly criticized Poshmark’s customer service after a return was denied despite the seller providing incorrect measurements and proof. (August 23rd, 2025)

• Poshmark live shows hurt regular closet sales: One seller complained that their previously strong sales have plummeted in recent months due to Poshmark’s focus on live shows. They noted that buyers are now mainly purchasing from these shows instead of individual closets. (August 22nd, 2025)

Which tool should you choose?

Your choice between Vinted and Poshmark reflects your priorities, available time, and business goals. We tested both platforms to reveal their strengths and limitations for different seller scenarios.

Choose Vinted if you …

• Want maximum profit margins: Vinted’s zero seller fees let you keep the full sale price, making it ideal for competitive sellers who want higher earnings.

• Prefer selling from your mobile devices: The platform features a native mobile app for iOS and Android, allowing users to quickly photograph and list items without extra steps.

• Sell internationally or focus on European markets: Vinted's strong presence across European countries provides access to international buyers, expanding the potential customer base beyond North American markets.

Choose Poshmark if you …

• Want built-in marketing and social discovery: Poshmark's social-media-like sharing system, Posh Parties, Posh Shows, and community features can improve item visibility and reach targeted buyers, all inside the platform.

• Sell authenticated items: The marketplace’s authentication services, buyer protection, and prepaid shipping labels reduce fraud risk for high-ticket items. 

• Prefer seller tools and analytics: Poshmark's detailed performance tracking, bulk editing capabilities, and Smart List AI help resellers optimize listings, track trends, and scale operations.

My final verdict

Both Vinted and Poshmark excel in different areas, providing value for specific sellers. Vinted maximizes profits by offering zero seller fees and appeals to individuals seeking quick mobile listing capabilities. Poshmark offers superior discovery tools, analytics, and community features, and appeals more to sellers based in North America.

Ready to try Nifty?

Choosing between Vinted vs. Poshmark comes down to your selling style and your location. Nifty lets you manage all your listings on Poshmark, plus those from Depop, Etsy, eBay, and Mercari (with more coming soon!), from one panel to maximize your reach. 

Here’s what else you get with Nifty: 

• Upload a photo and get a full listing: Nifty's AI transforms your image into professional listings with SEO titles, compelling descriptions, trending hashtags, and every dropdown field completed automatically.

• Automate repetitive tasks: Relist on all platforms, share on Poshmark daily, schedule listings in advance, and update prices in bulk.

• Track performance across platforms: Monitor sales, fees, top performers, and slow-moving inventory in one dashboard. Identify what works, what doesn't, and where to focus growth efforts.

Get started with a 7-day free trial and see why more sellers are using Nifty to save time, increase visibility, and ultimately, make more money.

FAQs

1. Which is better for reselling clothes: Vinted or Poshmark?

The best platform for reselling clothes is Vinted for maximum profit margins and Poshmark for sellers who value social discovery tools. The choice depends on your priorities and selling style. Vinted works best for sellers who want zero fees and a simple mobile listing. Poshmark suits sellers who want analytics and community engagement, despite the higher 20% commission fee that reduces profits.

2. Does Poshmark charge more fees than Vinted?

Yes, Poshmark charges significantly more fees than Vinted for sellers. Poshmark takes 20% commission on sales over $15 and $2.95 on sales under $15, whereas Vinted charges sellers zero fees. However, Vinted shifts costs to buyers through service fees, which can impact purchase decisions and overall sales volume.

3. Is Nifty a marketplace like Poshmark or Vinted?

No, Nifty is not a marketplace like Poshmark or Vinted. It’s a crosslisting, analytics, and automation tool that helps sellers manage their inventory across existing marketplaces, including Poshmark, Depop, Etsy, eBay, and Mercari. Nifty generates listings with AI, offers easy inventory management, and provides analytics for multi-platform selling operations.